As the lights dimmed inside the historic Victory Theatre in Evansville, Indiana, anticipation buzzed through the crowd. From either side of the stage, two guitarists began to strum the opening chords of Keith Whitley’s beloved classic, “I’m Over You.” The atmosphere was electric. Then, stepping into the spotlight, Sarah Beth Brewer emerged – greeted with warm applause and welcome from the audience. 

Opening for the renowned Deana Carter, Sarah Beth Brewer proved herself more than worthy of the stage. Carter, a five-time multi-platinum country artist, rose to fame in 1996 with her breakthrough album Did I Shave My Legs for This?, and is best known for the timeless hit “Strawberry Wine.” Sharing the stage with such a legend is no small feat, but Sarah Beth held her own with poise and talent. 

Hailing from Western Kentucky, Sarah Beth is quickly establishing herself as a rising force in country music. Her debut single, “Let Us Be,” has garnered attention on multiple Spotify playlists, including the coveted All New Country. During her set, the song took on a new life as guitarists Jacob Patton and Zachary Northrup offered a reimagined arrangement. Departing from the original’s iconic three-beat instrumental pause, they delivered a fuller, more dynamic progression that energized the room. 

One of the most powerful moments of the night came when Sarah Beth introduced an unreleased song, What You Left of Me. Before performing, she took a moment to speak candidly to the audience about the importance of mental health, reminding fans that they are not alone in their struggles. She emphasized the power of vulnerability through music, sharing how songwriting has helped her process pain and connect with others. The song, raw and emotionally charged, left the room in quiet reflection – a testament to her authenticity and depth as an artist.

Sarah Beth Brewer also showcased her versatility and roots in country music through a few standout covers. Her lively rendition of Sara Evans’ “Suds in the Bucket” had the audience clapping along joyfully (without any prompting) showing just how naturally she can lift the energy in a room. Later, she delivered a powerful version of Patty Loveless’s haunting “You’ll Never Leave Harlan Alive,” and the moment the first notes rang out, audience members recognized it instantly, screaming with excitement. Her vocal performance matched the song’s emotional weight, drawing goosebumps and cheers in equal measure. 

Fans in the audience weren’t just discovering Sarah Beth – they were returning to see her again. Elmer B., who drove over two hours to attend the show, was there for his third time seeing her live. “I first saw Sarah Beth in Huntingburg with William Michael Morgan,” he shared. “She’s just a joy to be around and so genuine. I’ve been a fan ever since.” 

With heartfelt lyrics, a warm stage presence, and a voice that resonates long after the final note, Sarah Beth Brewer is clearly on a trajectory that’s only going up. Her performance at Victory Theatre was more than just an opening set – it was a defining moment for an artist on the rise.